Thursday, July 15, 2010

WSJ fails to deliver in story on farmers and derivatives

Former NYT reporter Edmund Andrews delivered a devastating critique of a Tuesday WSJ story that purported to show that new financial regulations would hurt farmers. http://bit.ly/9ubTCE
As a former WSJ reporter I was shocked to read through the whole story and find no evidence of actual impacts. Worse, there wasn't even any cogent explanation of how any individual farmer was likely to be directly impacted.
I admired the Journal for going beyond the usual Washington-bureau article about vote-counting on the Senate floor and whether there are enough Republicans signing on to make it a bi-partisan bill. We need more stories that look at the real world impact of what Washington does.
But it's disappointing when a reporter goes out to Nebraska, talks to some pretty intelligent farmers, dealers and co-op managers and comes back with a story that doesn't actually demonstrate that the legislation will have any impact. At the least, the reporter should have found someone to say that spreads on derivative contracts are likely to rise by two-cents per hundredweight or something. Then we could get some idea of the magnitude of the issue.
As Ed wrote, the headline certainly led readers to expect more than the story delivered.

1 comment:

  1. People are very happy because you can get both the Christian Louboutin shoes quality and the design when you buy Christian Louboutin Pumps sale. You will acknowledge Christian Louboutin Sandals that not too many other companies are able to do that for you like the Christian Louboutin Boots sale.

    The piano lesson MANNIX schedule may not fit with everybody’s MANNIX DVD COLLECTION timing, or the hourly consultation cost of such MANNIX DVD professional guitarists may be far more than expected.

    Hogan not only strength train your legs and bare feet, imitating the motion, maximizing cushioning, support and multi-surface traction. To get your feet even more involved during your run, the Hogan scarpe uomo has deep flex grooves that enhance the foot's flexibility and stability. If you're ready for the benefits of barefoot training but require a Hogan scarpe donna with a plusher feel than others in the Hogan uomo , don't overlook this shoe's heel design-a new addition to the series–which delivers a cushioning experience that won't compromise your flexibility.

    ReplyDelete